Email us at:
About us
NY Pizza Suprema was established in 1964 in this location by my father Salvatore Riggio, an Italian immigrant. This pizzeria was here before Madison Square Garden moved here. At that time the school around the corner currently named TCI was RCA. When Sal decided to raise the price from 5 cents a slice, the RCA students picketed in front of the pizzeria for several days, catching media attention. From 1964 and all the way up to 1988, Sal only served plain cheese slices. If you wanted anything extra on your slice, you had to buy the whole pie.
Read moreOur Opening Hours
- Monday : 10:30am-12:00am
- Tuesday : 10:30am-12:00am
- Wednesday : 10:30am-12:00am
- Thursday : 10:30am-12:00am
- Friday : 10:30am-12:00am
- Saturday : 10:30am-12:00am
- Sunday : 10:30am-12:00am
Featured Items
Signature Pizzas
What more can we say, our pizzas are the best in the city, we make our pizzas from scratch! Top them with whatever you want and have it your way.
Delicious Calzones & Rolls
Imported Romano and the finest Ricotta and Grande Mozzarella cheeses
Specialty Pizza Pies
If you are feeling more adventurous, check out any of our Specialty Pizzas like our Grandma special Pie. We have a ton of choices!
Specialty Slices
-
$4.50Grandma Pizza
Thin crust, Sicilian style Fresh Mozzarella, fresh tomato, fresh crushed garlic, imported Pecorino Romano cheese, finished with fresh basil and imported extra virgin olive oil
-
$3.50Upside Down Pizza
A first cousin of the "New York style" Sicilian. This is the true Sicilian pie and another famous signature pie. A sauce lover's favorite the finest Grande Mozzarella covers a light and airy deep dish square crust
-
$5.00Suprema Special Pizza
Our namesake pie. Our round pie topped with all the favorites - fine sweet Italian sausage, pepperoni, sauteed onions, fresh roasted red peppers and fresh mushrooms
-
$3.50Sicilian Pizza
Good old "New York style" Sicilian a cooked onion based sauce, sprinkled with imported Italian Romano cheese, covered with the finest Grande Mozzarella and all this on a light and airy deep dish square crust
-
$4.50White Pizza
A cheese lover's favorite! Oozing with imported Romano and the finest Ricotta and Grande Mozzarella cheeses.Sprinkled with fresh Garlic. No sauce
-
$4.50Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Our famous round pie topped with buffalo chicken
-
$5.00Chicken and Broccoli Pizza
Our round pie topped with lightly breaded white meat chicken cutlet & broccoli, with just a touch of fresh garlic
-
$4.50Veggie Medley - Vegan Friendly Pizza
On a light airy Sicilian crust, diced fresh tomatoes, black olives, onions & fresh mushrooms that are sauteed with fresh garlic in imported extra virgin olive oil
